I was a classmate of Nick at Sinai. We shared a developing love for careers in surgery. He was smart, fun, and mostly a kind and considerate peer and friend. He will be missed.

I still can’t believe Dr Gargiulo is gone. He was a wonderful human being. I worked with him at Montefiore and at South Side Hospitals. I will never his generosity and professionalism.

I send my deepest condolences to the family, friends and colleagues of Dr. G’s. He was my vascular doctor. To learn of his death brought great sadness and disbelief. He was a big advocate for his patients in regards to taking caring of themselves. He was extremely kind and thorough. He made you feel like family. Dr. G will truly be missed and I’ll never forget the way he cared for me as a doctor..Never rushed or overlooked. Truly one of one! 🥺My heart is shattered

I was a medical student who trained under Dr. Gargulio, the news of his passing comes as a sad and bitter shock. He was always so kind and encouraging. He was the only surgeon who didn’t have an ego and made his students and patients feel welcomed. He was a smart surgeon, who was passionate and kind to his patients. He has left an impact on many of his students and patients lives, and we can only hope to be a doctor like him.

Nick and I were freshman-year roommates at Colgate University. While life took us in different directions, we rekindled our friendship years ago and planned to attend our 35th reunion next May 2026.

My thoughts and prayers go out to his family, friends, colleagues, and patients. He was a wonderful man and a talented physician, but those of us who knew him nearly 40 years ago will remember his sense of humor, intelligence, and kindness.

I first met Nick when he was a fellow at Montefiore under Frank Veith. His passing comes as a sad and bitter shock. He was a very kind and compassionate person who was always very welcoming. My heartfelt condolences to his entire family.

Dr. Gargulio’s death came as such a shock. I could not believe what I was hearing, yet seeing him at peace, with his eyes closed, brought a sense of comfort.

I have known Dr. Gargulio since 2017. I was very new to the sales industry and still learning how to work, how to carry myself, and how to navigate that world. I remember my first OR case as a vendor and feeling so nervous, unsure of what would be expected of me. Thankfully, it was with Dr. Gargulio.

He had a way of making people feel comfortable and making even a stressful environment feel easy. Being around him felt like being at the home of a beloved family member, just talking while he worked. He was incredibly inclusive and made sure everyone felt part of the conversation and at home. He may have been a surgeon, but he never carried the ego of one.

He was one of the kindest human beings I have ever had the privilege of meeting, and I thank God that I did.

He loved nostalgia and would often talk about his time at Colgate, at Northwell, and at Upstate, where he met his wife, Marina. He would also speak about his life at Brookdale Hospital and loved proudly showing photos of his young boys. He had such a deep empathy for the residents and would say, “Mira, I just want them to enjoy life a bit and not feel caged here. Life should be enjoyed.”

And yet, he worked countless hours serving the underserved community in Brooklyn. I still remember him saying, “Brooklyn is the largest borough.” I actually learned that from him.

He was truly an angel in human form who has now returned to being an angel. I am so grateful that our paths crossed. Until next time.

My deepest condolences to all of Dr. Gargulio’s family and children. I had the chance to meet his daughter Olivia, and his sons Rafael and Gabriel, all of whom share Dr. Gargulio’s beautiful smile and laughter. It brings me comfort to know that his smile and laugh will live on through them and continue to be seen and felt by so many.

What a tragic loss. He was so easy to talk to and was such a nice, warm and genuine person that always managed to share his thoughts and expereinces. He will be missed.

Deepest condolences to the Gargiulo family.

I knew Nicholas as a surgical resident at Montefiore and later as an attending.
My condolences to the family . Nicholas was one of the kindest and most compassionate physicians I ever trained as an attending surgeon.

Dr G was the best Dr i had he didn't just listen he heard me and he did everything he could to help me.his passing knocked the wind out of me when I found out yesterday. I will truly miss him there will never be another Dr Gargiulo when God made him he broke the mold.

It is very heartbreaking to learn of the passing of Dr. G. He was my vascular doctor whom I would see at his office at St. Jude's on Flatlands Avenue or at Brookdale Hospital. Dr. "G", as I affectionately called him was a very pleasant, caring kind, patient and compassionate human being. He had a smile and a welcoming demeanor. If I didn't understand certain things, he would take the time to explain the situation to me. I just loved that man. He gave me his cell phone # to call him if I had any changes in my feet. If I called him and he didn't answer right away, he would definitely call me back no matter what. I had an appointment to see him in June. I had been seeing him for a few years, now my favourite vascular doctor is gone to be
with his Lord and Savior. Sleep on Dr. G and get your rest. God knows that your work here on earth finished, so he took you home. Rest in peace, Dr. Gargiulo. May the light of God perpetually shine on you forever. Goodbye
my doctor!

Dr. G was one of the best doctors I’ve had the privilege of working with. I was lucky to work with him a few times, and he was always easygoing and humble. He was not only a physician, but a true teacher and educator. I learned so many life lessons from him. He genuinely cared about his colleagues and always made a point to check on their well-being. He will be greatly missed. Rest in peace 🕊️

I worked with Dr. Gargiulo at Montefiore Medical Center and have known him for over 25 years. I remember how happy he was sharing pictures of his children every time I saw him. He was always kind and considerate. I will miss him dearly!! My condolences to his family. Rest in Peace Dr. G!

Dear Garguilo family,
I am so sorry to hear about Dr. Gargiulo’s untimely passing. He was an integral part of our MBA cohort and he always had heartfelt insight for our projects. He represented his work with honor and respect and he will be missed by all of his friends and colleagues.

Nick was one of the kindest people I ever met. Always a smile on his face and kind words. I am still in shock over his passing. You surely will be missed. May your soul rest in Peace. God Bless .

Dear Garguilo family, my deepest sympathy goes out to you on the loss of Dr. Nicholas. He performed vascular surgery on my sister's feet. We will ever be greatful to him. May his soul rest in peace and rise in Glory. May God wrap His loving arms around each and every one of you.

I will always remember Dr G as a selfless and caring doctor. He often shared wisdom from Scripture with me, and they were a source of comfort. He loved his family deeply and his kindness touched so many. I will miss him dearly. My condolences to his family and may God give them strength during this difficult time. May he rest in peace.

Rest in peace, Dr.G s we called you a healer whose compassion and dedication touched countless lives. Through long days and sleepless nights, you gave your strength to ease the pain of others, offering not just medicine, but hope and comfort. Your kindness will be remembered in every life you helped heal and every heart you reassured.Though you are no longer with us, your legacy lives on in the difference you made and the inspiration you leave behind. May you find the peace and rest you give so selflessly to others.

caring, compassionate, and humble individual has left this earth. He was a great communicator who always took his time with each person. His family was his lifeline. I got to know a little about all of them without ever meeting them.
I will miss seeing you wear 10K per shoe covers and opening 10K gloves for you. I will miss our very interesting routine conversations. I’ve been scrubbing with Dr G almost every single week for the past year, and there has never been a single dull moment or a time when he was upset.
God truly created a special soul in Dr. G. Until we meet again.

Dear Gargiulo Family,
Please accept my deepest condolences on the sudden passing of Dr. Gargiulo.

Dr. Gargiulo was a student in the MBA program at Hofstra and I had the privilege of interacting with him not only as one of his professors but also as a part of directing him through the program. His smile and nice/warm/calm demeanor during our numerous conversations will remain with me as a memory.

This is so shocking!! May you all have all the strength that you need during this incredibly difficult time. Rest in peace, Dr. Gargiulo.

Dr. Nicholas Garguilo was a wonderful, friendly, caring Surgeon. He was such a nice man with a terrific sense of humor. He would always go out of his way to help someone even with his very demanding schedule. He was charming, engaging and super smart. I will miss him as he such was a great guy. My sincere condolences to his family.

Dear Gargiulo Family,

I am deeply saddened to hear of the sudden passing of Dr. Nicholas Joseph Gargiulo III. I had the privilege of being his classmate in our MBA program, and I will always remember him as a kind, thoughtful, and genuinely warm person.

His presence brought positivity to those around him, and he will be truly missed. Please accept my heartfelt condolences during this incredibly difficult time. My thoughts are with you and your family.

With deepest sympathy,

I had the privilege of meeting Dr. Gargiulo a few months ago at Brookdale Hospital, where I was the attending nurse for a couple of his patients in ICU. Dr. Gargiulo embodied compassion and patience, taking the time to personally connect with each patient, addressing their concerns and fostering a sense of comfort. The last time I saw and spoke with Dr. Gargiulo was on Friday morning morning March 13th, during his routine rounds, where he continued to inspire with his kindness. The news of his departure has had a profound impact on me. Dr. Gargiulo was an exemplary individual, whose kindness, patience, and warm smile will be deeply missed, yet his legacy will continue to inspire us all. Sleep In Peace Dr. Gargiulo.

Dr. Gargiulo was a highly respected physician who touched countless lives through his dedication and compassionate care. He will be remembered for his warmth, wisdom and unwavering commitment to the Flatlands team. You will be missed Dr. G

Dr G , wonderful person. I will miss his smile Great Doctor . To the family I'm sorry for your loss. Words can't take the pain away, But know that love is always near, In memories cherished, they're still here. Miriam Vazquez

I have know Dr. Gargiulo for many years. We first meet in KJMC, before Brookdale Hospital. He was loved so dearly by all of his patients. Dr Gargiulo sets a standard that many can follow as a physician. He will be missed and his love that he shared with many will be remember. I know that Dr Gargiulo has earn his wings and is resting in perfect peace

Dr. G was one of the easiest people to talk to—warm, approachable, and genuinely present in every interaction. No matter how busy his schedule was, he always made time to say “hi,” “hello,” or share a quick moment of kindness with every member of the staff.
He carried himself with a friendliness that made our workplace feel lighter, brighter, and more human. His spirit was gentle, his heart sincere, and his presence unforgettable.
Such a wonderful soul… one who touched many lives simply by being himself.
Dr. G, you will be deeply missed, but your warmth and kindness will continue to live on in all of us who were fortunate enough to know you.

Dr. Nick is a man who was so much more than a talented vascular surgeon. He was a rare soul who remained completely "down to earth" despite his many achievements. He never looked down on anyone, treating every patient and colleague with the same profound respect.
​
​Rest in peace, Dr. Nick. Your legacy of humility and grace lives on in the many lives you touched. We will surely miss you!

Nick was a personal friend as well as a mentor. Nick was the kindest, most compassionate physician I have met in my entire medical sales career. I will miss our spiritual debates and family conversations tremendously.
– The lights in Brooklyn shine a little bit dimmer tonight but I am certain Heaven shines quite a bit brighter as the angels welcome him home.

Nick was a true professional with exceptional charisma. I am truly saddened by his passing and I hope that he did not suffer during his last moments. May the Lord God bless him and grant him eternal peace.

Dr. G was one of the kindest surgeon you can work with. He always had a demeanor of a gentleman with a big heart. We will always remember him. Rest in peace doctor.

Working alongside you was an honor. Your skill, precision, and dedication to your patients will never be forgotten. Your legacy lives on in every life you touched and every lesson you passed on. Rest peacefully, Dr.G 💐 🙏

It was a pleasure working alongside you in the OR. Your kindness and cheerful personality will never be forgotten. Rest in peace Dr. G.

Dr. G-always ready with a bright smile and a cheery hello. He will be missed. Our loss is heaven's gain...RIP

I had the privilege of working with Dr. Gargiulo for many years in the operating room. One of the qualities that always stood out was his remarkable ability to know everyone’s name in the room, no matter their role. He treated every individual with genuine respect and kindness, regardless of their title or position. His humility and professionalism will leave a lasting impression on all of us who had the opportunity to work alongside him, and he will be deeply missed.

Nick could really make you laugh. He had the most amazing stories. I will miss our talks on my commutes when he kept me company on the phone.

Dr. G, was such a pleasant soul, dedicated, easy to talk to, always giving advice, always has a smile on his face, you will surely be missed, sleep in eternal peace Dr. G

Kindest person anyone can ever meet. He was truly a Saint, our Saint Nick who I am certain is in Heaven. He was so much more than a Doctor to his patients, he was so much more than a friend to all. You will be missed Dr. G

Dr.Gargiulo wasn't just someone I worked with, he was wonderful person. Whether offering help before being asked or checking in after a tough day, he went beyond what was expected. I missed him not just a colleague, but as a friend.